2004 All-CACC Men's Soccer Team
| First Team | ||||
| GK | Bryan Rudden | Goldey-Beacom | Sr. | Landenberg, PA |
| D | Dan Corti | Nyack | Jr. | Lakewood, NJ |
| D | Alberto Guerra | Nyack | Sr. | Guatemala City, Guatamala |
| D | Tom Rolston | Dominican | Jr. | New City, NY |
| M | Oswald Adu | Nyack | Fr. | Ontario, Canada |
| M | Bruno Farias | Goldey-Beacom | Jr. | Recife, Brazil |
| M | Elvis Langa | Nyack | Sr. | Maputo, Mozambique |
| F | Kyle Clancy | Dominican | Jr. | Walden, NY |
| F | Matt DiGiacobbe | Goldey-Beacom | Sr. | Newark, DE |
| F | Nick Levinson | Felician | Jr. | Palisades Park, NJ |
| F | Bard Skjelstad | Caldwell | So. | Bodo, Norway |
| Second Team | ||||
| GK | Kieran McGovern | Dominican | Jr. | Fair Lawn, NJ |
| GK | Rob Renaurt | Nyack | Sr. | Lakewood, NJ |
| D | Dario Fiorino | Felician | Sr. | Montreal, Canada |
| D | Siggi Flosason | Felician | Jr. | Reykyavik, Iceland |
| D | Andrew Fraser | Caldwell | Fr. | Kingston, Jamaica |
| D | Jan Marco Jiras | Caldwell | Fr. | Lima, Peru |
| M | Jared Hughart | Wilmington | Jr. | Townsent, DE |
| M | Jorge Ibarcena | Caldwell | So. | Lima, Peru |
| M | Christian Quinga | Dominican | Jr. | Stamford, CT |
| F | Ryan Clancy | Dominican | Fr. | Walden, NY |
| F | Hyogo Kobayashi | Post | Sr. | Hiroshima, Japan |
| F | Jim Latronica | Holy Family | Fr. | Levittown, PA |
Player of the Year: Kyle Clancy, Dominican
Newcomer of the Year: Tim Conway, Nyack
Coach of the Year: Michael Swanwick, Dominican
Team Sportsmanship Award: Post